Real Estate

What Is ‘Good Cause Eviction,’ and What Does It Mean for Renters?

New York renters are feeling the squeeze, with rents in Manhattan up 32 p.c in April from the identical time a 12 months in the past, in accordance with a report, and housing courts busy as evictions resume after a pandemic moratorium. Some renters are questioning: Is there any aid? Tenant advocates say sure, pointing to a invoice launched final 12 months within the New York State Legislature referred to as Prohibition of Eviction Without Good Cause. However what’s “good trigger eviction,” and what would it not imply for renters and landlords if the invoice, because it stands now, turns into legislation?

Below present legislation, landlords usually are not required to supply new leases to market-rate tenants. Good trigger eviction would require them to supply new leases, although tenants may nonetheless be evicted for lease violations, like failure to pay hire or for different infractions.

Good trigger eviction “offers you confidence that you could elevate children” in your condo, mentioned Judith Goldiner, a Authorized Assist Society lawyer who helped write the laws. “You don’t have to fret about being evicted.”

Comparable legal guidelines exist already in New Jersey, California and Oregon, in addition to in a number of New York municipalities together with Albany, Beacon, Kingston, Newburgh and Poughkeepsie.


Within the invoice sponsored by New York State Senator Julia Salazar, hire will increase could be capped at 3 p.c or 1.5 occasions the annual p.c change within the Shopper Worth Index, whichever is greater. So, in case your hire is $2,000 a month, it may go up this 12 months by as a lot as 12.5 percent, or $250. However the invoice additionally offers landlords room for even greater will increase in the event that they present that their prices have gone up or that they’ve made enhancements.

This invoice expands protections for tenants, overlaying basically all renters in unregulated housing, with just a few exceptions, equivalent to owner-occupied buildings with fewer than 4 items. The Community Service Society estimates that the invoice would have an effect on 1.6 million households statewide — about half of all renters.

Tenants could be lined in the event that they hire flats in market-rate high-rises, are on month-to-month rental agreements, hire condos or co-op items from personal house owners, hire single-family properties or sublet flats from different tenants.

Renters lined by the invoice may nonetheless lose their flats if property house owners reclaim the house for private use.

Landlords and their advocates fear that the invoice, because it at present stands, might result in extra housing court docket circumstances as tenants problem hire will increase, and that it casts a web so broad that it will have an effect on property house owners who won’t contemplate themselves landlords in a conventional sense, like house owners of single-family properties, tenants who sublet, and co-op and apartment house owners who hire out their flats.

Ann Korchak, the board president of Small Property Homeowners of New York, a landlord advocacy group with roughly 600 members, mentioned she was involved that the laws would prohibit landlords from emptying their properties to promote or take again just because they not wished to hire them out. “It appears close to inconceivable for house owners to reclaim their properties,” she mentioned.

Ms. Korchak, whose household owns two brownstones on the Higher West Facet, additionally expressed considerations about capping hire will increase in an inflationary setting. “It’s simply not real looking to suppose that the rising prices on the proprietor’s aspect usually are not going to be handed on to” tenants, she mentioned. “That’s the best way the financial system works.”

For weekly electronic mail updates on residential actual property information, enroll right here. Observe us on Twitter: @nytrealestate.

Show More

Related Articles

Back to top button